Guide To Preparing Students for Graduate School in Physics and Related Fields

Version 2022.1

This section provides recommendations for how physics programs can educate their undergraduate students about and prepare them for a variety of graduate programs, including doctoral programs and master’s programs in physics or related STEM fields. While this section focuses on STEM, much of the guidance in this section may also be relevant for preparing students for graduate school in other fields. The sections on High School Physics Teacher Preparation and Career Preparation provide more detailed and specific guidance on preparing students for teaching careers and other careers. See the section on Dual-Degree Programs for information about creating, maintaining, and recruiting students into dual-degree programs, e.g., 4+1 or 3+2 programs, that are hosted at your institution or in partnership with another institution.

Benefits

Many physics students pursue graduate studies, yet preparation for graduate school often falls into the “hidden curriculum” that programs assume students already know or will pick up on their own. Making graduate school preparation an explicit part of your curriculum can help ensure that all your students have the same access to opportunities as those students who have learned about graduate school elsewhere, and as students in other programs that already prepare their students for graduate school. Deliberately preparing students for graduate school in a variety of fields can support equity by enhancing the potential for students, particularly those from

Marginalized Groups

People of color and others with marginalized ethnicities, women and others who experience misogyny, LGBTQ+ people, disabled people, and others who have traditionally been marginalized in society and in physics. According to the TEAM-UP Report, marginalized groups are “groups of people defined by a common social identity who lack adequate social power or resources to design, build, or perpetuate social structures or institutions that reflect the centrality … of their identities, proclivities, and points of view. … They need not be underrepresented or numerical minorities, but often are.” We use the term marginalized groups, rather than minorities, underrepresented groups, or other commonly used terms, because people in these groups are not always minorities or underrepresented, and in order to convey that underrepresentation is the result of marginalization rather than a statistical accident. Another common term is minoritized groups. While we use this general term for brevity and readability, it is important to recognize that the many different groups encompassed by this term face different challenges and have different needs that should be addressed individually whenever possible, to learn the terms that people ask to be called, and to recognize that these terms may change over time.

, to attend, persist at, and succeed in graduate school. The practices in this section can help your department improve recruiting and retention in both undergraduate and graduate programs. Improved graduate outcomes can also help your institution recruit students, meet accreditation requirements, and strengthen alumni connections.

The Cycle of Reflection and Action

Effective Practices

Effective Practices

  1. Support students in the admissions process

  2. Help students develop skills for success in graduate school

  3. Support all your students in developing a sense of belonging and identity as potential graduate students

Programmatic Assessments

Programmatic Assessments

Finding graduate programs and succeeding in graduate school

  • American Institute of Physics, GradSchoolShopper: A comprehensive online source for researching graduate programs in the physical sciences, engineering, and related fields. Provides detailed information on graduate programs in physics, applied physics, and engineering physics in the US, Canada, and Mexico.
  • R. Snieder and K. Larner, The Art of Being a Scientist: A Guide for Graduate Students and their Mentors, Cambridge University Press (2009): A guide for graduate students and prospective graduate students on how to choose a research topic, department, and advisor; make work plans; understand research ethics; use scientific literature; communicate; publish papers; write proposals; manage time effectively; plan a scientific career; and apply for jobs in research and industry.

Preparing graduate school applications

Preparing for Graduate Record Exams (GREs)

Equity and inclusion in graduate admissions

  • APS Bridge Program: An

    APS

    American Physical Society. Website

    -led program that increases the number of

    Black

    A person or people of African ancestry. We use this term, rather than African American, because it is becoming the preferred term, and to be more inclusive of people who can’t trace their lineage to a specific country in Africa and/or those who are not American. We capitalize this term to acknowledge that it represents certain shared experiences, rather than just a race or skin color.

    ,

    Latinx

    A person or people of Latin American ancestry. We use this term, rather than Latino, Latina, Latino/a, or Latino/Latina (which assume a gender binary), to be more inclusive of all genders; rather than Hispanic, to be more inclusive of those who are not from Spanish-speaking countries and/or not of Spanish ancestry; and rather than other gender-neutral terms such as Latine, Latin@, Latinic, Latin, or Latin American, because it is more likely to be recognized and understood. However, we acknowledge that the term Latinx has been criticized as being a term that is more accessible to English-speakers than to Spanish speakers (because it does not follow Spanish linguistic or pronunciation rules) and that is not used by many of the people it represents.

    , and

    Indigenous

    Descendants of those who inhabited a country or a geographical region at the time when people of different cultures or ethnic origins arrived. In the U.S., this term may include Native Americans and the Indigenous people of Hawaii, Alaska, Puerto Rico, Guam, etc.

    students who earn PhDs in physics by ​​creating sustainable transition programs for graduate students at a national network of doctoral-granting institutions, and by providing undergraduate ​​students with research experience, advanced coursework, and coaching to prepare them for a graduate school application.
  • Conferences for Undergraduate Women and Gender Minorities in Physics (CU*iP): Conferences, previously known as Conferences for Undergraduate Women in Physics (CUWiP), for undergraduate women and gender minorities to explore education and career opportunities, find mentors, and learn from fellow students who are women, gender diverse individuals and underrepresented identities in physics.
  • B. Beckford et al., “The Time is Now: Systemic Changes for Increasing African Americans in Physics & Astronomy” (TEAM-UP report), American Institute of Physics (2020): The

    AIP

    American Institute of Physics. Website

    National Task Force to Elevate African American Representation in Undergraduate Physics & Astronomy (TEAM-UP) investigated the reasons for the persistent underrepresentation of African Americans in physics and astronomy and produced a report with its findings and evidence-based recommendations to increase the number of African Americans earning physics and astronomy bachelor’s degrees. The recommendations, especially on the topic of physics identity, also include practices that influence whether students consider pursuing graduate studies in the physical sciences.
  • A. L. Rudolf, “Cal-Bridge: Creating pathways to the PhD for underrepresented students in physics and astronomy,” Physics Today 72(10), 50–57 (2019): The Cal-Bridge program focuses on preparing students from

    Marginalized Groups

    People of color and others with marginalized ethnicities, women and others who experience misogyny, LGBTQ+ people, disabled people, and others who have traditionally been marginalized in society and in physics. According to the TEAM-UP Report, marginalized groups are “groups of people defined by a common social identity who lack adequate social power or resources to design, build, or perpetuate social structures or institutions that reflect the centrality … of their identities, proclivities, and points of view. … They need not be underrepresented or numerical minorities, but often are.” We use the term marginalized groups, rather than minorities, underrepresented groups, or other commonly used terms, because people in these groups are not always minorities or underrepresented, and in order to convey that underrepresentation is the result of marginalization rather than a statistical accident. Another common term is minoritized groups. While we use this general term for brevity and readability, it is important to recognize that the many different groups encompassed by this term face different challenges and have different needs that should be addressed individually whenever possible, to learn the terms that people ask to be called, and to recognize that these terms may change over time.

    at the California universities and community colleges that participate in the program for graduate school in STEM fields, and can serve as a model for other programs with similar goals. The sections in this article on “Mentoring,” “Cohort Building and Professional Development,” and “Research Experience” are particularly helpful for learning about effective practices for preparing students for graduate school in the context of equity and inclusion.
  • University of Arizona Commission on the Status of Women, Avoiding gender bias in reference writing (2016).

Graduate fellowships

See Resources in the section on Undergraduate Research for resources for finding undergraduate research programs.

See Resources in the section on Career Preparation for resources for supporting students in learning about the diversity of careers available with various degrees.

See Resources in the section on Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion for recommendations for inclusive graduate admissions.

The guidance in this section is supported by data on graduate education and careers in physics [1] and by reports on equity, diversity, and inclusion in physics and astronomy graduate programs [2 and 3].

  1. AIP Statistical Research Center: A group that regularly collects and analyzes data on education, careers, and diversity in physics, astronomy, and other physical sciences. Their collection of reports on graduate education provides current data and historic trends, including on student demographics, educational experiences, and post-degree plans. Additionally, their resource Physics Bachelors: Initial Employment contains information about undergraduates choosing to pursue graduate studies, and their reports on PhD recipients’ employment, master’s degree recipients’ employment, and bachelor’s degree recipients’ employment provide data for comparing salaries for different degrees.AIP National Task Force to Elevate African American Representation in Undergraduate Physics & Astronomy (TEAM-UP), “The Time is Now: Systemic Changes for Increasing African Americans in Physics & Astronomy” American Institute of Physics (2020).
  2. AIP National Task Force to Elevate African American Representation in Undergraduate Physics & Astronomy (TEAM-UP), “The Time is Now: Systemic Changes for Increasing African Americans in Physics & Astronomy,” American Institute of Physics (2020).
  3. A. Rudolf et al., Final Report of the 2018 AAS Task Force on Diversity and Inclusion in Astronomy Graduate Education (2018): Recommendations on admissions practices and data on graduate admissions.
Stay Informed with Updates
Our quarterly newsletter keeps you in the loop about events, ways to get involved, and the latest EP3 Guide content.
By signing up, I agree to the APS Privacy Policy.
EP3 Logo

Brought to you by


Funding provided by

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant Nos. 1738311, 1747563, and 1821372. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.

This site is governed by the APS Privacy and other policies.

© 2024 The American Physical Society
CC-BY-NC-SA